How to Handle Fraudulent Unemployment Insurance Claims

Andy M. Haynie - CPA, CFE

Originally from Tangier Island, VA, Andy began working for Leatherbury-Broache and Company upon graduating from Salisbury University in 1998. He joined PKS in 2000, and became a Partner in 2012. Andy lives in Marion Station with his wife Amy and two sons, Thomas and Conner. Outside of work he loves spending time with his family. A typical weekend for Andy includes traveling for soccer with his boys or on a rare occasion going to the beach to relax. He is constantly listening to music, collects vinyl records (old and new) and will see as many live music shows in a year as possible. Andy is also an avid runner and participates in a number of regional races through the year with distances ranging from 5ks to 50ks.

The Department of Labor’s Employment and Training Administration (ETA) reports “unprecedented increases in unemployment insurance (UI) claims amid the pandemic and related surges in fraudulent filing in states’ systems by sophisticated criminal rings.” This has caused widespread problems for states, employers and employees alike.

Innocent employees have had claims filed in their names, employers are winding up with higher UI premiums, and some state UI systems have been unable to keep up with the increased work necessary to fight the fraud. In response, the ETA has issued guidance to state UI departments on stricter standards for verifying the legitimacy of claims before paying benefits.

The explosion in sophisticated criminal activity is in addition to lower-level fraud perpetrated by former employees. Some laid-off workers who receive UI benefits may not report their new working status when they become reemployed. Or laid-off employees may claim they’re meeting eligibility requirements for unemployment benefits, such as actively looking for work, when they aren’t doing so.

Note: Until recently, pandemic-related emergency unemployment provisions eased the requirement to actively look for work. That’s changing fast, state by state. Also, the $300 weekly “federal pandemic unemployment compensation” benefit is due to expire September 6, 2021.

Detecting Schemes

How does UI fraud come to light? Here are some common scenarios:

  • A laid-off worker applies for UI benefits and in the process discovers that a claim has already been filed in his or her name.
  • An employed or unemployed worker receives a notice from the state’s UI office that he or she has filed a UI claim, even though the worker hasn’t.
  • A worker receives a Form 1099-G with an amount of unemployment benefits the employee has allegedly received that’s subject to taxation.
  • A worker’s UI account has been funded and benefits are about to be paid when the fraudster who initiated the claim contacts that employee and seeks to have the payment diverted to him or her.
  • An employer receives a notice from the state’s UI office that a current employee has filed a claim, yet when contacted, the employee knows nothing about it.

Preventing Eligibility Errors

What can your organization do to keep ineligible claims from being charged to your UI account? Your first line of defense is to carefully scrutinize any notifications you receive from your state employment agency when a UI claim is filed. For example, an individual might indeed have been a former employee, but if his or her employment wasn’t recent enough, you might not be liable. Keeping your state employment agency up to date can help prevent such claims.

If you receive a notice about a former employee, review the circumstances of the worker’s departure. If the person voluntarily resigned or was terminated for “cause,” that individual is likely ineligible for unemployment benefits.

Given that much of the UI fraud involves identity theft, make sure that employees understand that their personal data may be at risk and provide training to prevent hacks. For example, ensure they don’t click on links and attachments contained in emails from unfamiliar senders. Also, your own organization’s cyber defense strategy should be continually updated to protect not only HR files, but also customer records, intellectual property and other critical data.

Responding to Fraud

If an employee’s name is used in a false UI claim, learn as much as you can about the extent of the fraud. This will help you determine what you and your employees might be facing — whether its unemployment benefit filings or more widespread identity theft. If you determine that your organization has been hacked, be sure to notify all affected individuals and work with your IT department to take immediate steps to guard against further attacks.

To help support affected workers, direct them to identity theft pages on the Federal Trade Commission website at The FTC is the government’s primary consumer protection agency and fraud authority. Ensure that employees have reported any false UI claim to their state and received a written response from the state acknowledging that the claim has been marked as fraudulent. You might also direct workers to regularly check their credit reports for signs of identity theft.

Working with the State

If UI benefits are paid to a fraudster who has used the identity of one or more of your employees and the fraudulent payments were charged to your UI account, you may have to work with the state unemployment agency to rectify the matter. Your prospects for winning this battle are better if you’ve kept the agency up-to-date, and perhaps even alerted the agency about potential false claims.

An improving economy and falling unemployment are expected to reduce UI fraud. But it would be a mistake to assume these schemes will disappear anytime soon. Fraud perpetrators are always on the lookout for opportunities to fleece companies and individuals.

PKS & Company, P. A. is a full service accounting firm with offices in Salisbury, Ocean City and Lewes that provides traditional accounting services as well as specialized services in the areas of retirement plan audits and administration, medical practice consulting, estate and trust services, fraud and forensic services and payroll services and offers financial planning and investments through PKS Investment Advisors, LLC.

© Copyright 2021. All rights reserved.
Brought to you by: PKS & Company, P.A.

Get Updates From PKS & Company, P.A.

Enter your email address to get our monthly newsletter and important updates regarding financial advice, tax code changes and more. 





Important Things to Know about 529 College Savings Account Withdrawals

Have you set up Section 529 college savings plans for your children or grandchildren? The major advantage of 529 plans is that qualified withdrawals a
Read Full Article



Elder Scams: Don’t Take the Bait

Today, virtually everyone is vulnerable to fraud schemes, from teenagers searching social media to middle-aged people making online purchases and s
Read Full Article



New Requirements for Long-Term, Part-Time Employees

For years, 401(k) plans have been able to follow the ERISA statutory provision that permits excluding employees who work less than 1,000 hours per y
Read Full Article